Five Rectangles

In Year 4 we've been looking at a puzzle, taken from Gary Antonick's 'Numberplay' in the New York Times:

Create a set of five rectangles that have sides of length 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10 units.

The really quick and easy way to explore this is with Cuisenaire rods:

After we'd found five rectangles with those side lengths, we recorded them using the Cuisenaire Environment:

Here are more pictures:


Then we started looking at the area the rectangles covered.

We got total areas of
120, 121, 123, 125, 130, 154, 161 and 184.

Next question: what is the biggest possible area?

Alicia answered this - use the biggest side lengths on the same rectangles:

Area = 190

Can you see why this is the maximum?

And then, what is the smallest possible area?

Mimi answered this one - use biggest and smallest lengths on the same rectangle:

Area = 110

Can you see why this is the minimum?

This is a great investigation - manageable, easy to understand, and susceptible to taking off in many directions. We didn't try to see how many possible ways of making the rectangles there are - that was a step too far.

But just seeing some of the ways was worthwhile. It works well because the rods and the numbers 1 to 10 are easy to grasp. And the maths it takes us into is worth it - length, area, 2 X 3 = 3 X 2, multiplication facts, addition of five numbers... And then a bit of more abstract thinking - what would the maximum and minimum be, and why.

It may be the first time a class has tackled this particular puzzle. We can certainly recommend it to other classes!

We rounded this investigation off with a small puzzle: 

Make these rectangles, and then see if you can make a square by putting them together:
 1x6 4x7 5x8 3x9 2x10
 3x6 4x7 2x8 1x9 5x10 
1x2 4x5 3x8 7x9 6x10
 1x2 4x6 3x7 8x9 5x10

Also blogged on the Year 4 blog.

Year 4 dodecagons

Year 4 used pattern blocks each make  a different regular dodecagons (= 12-sided shape). At first they were tricky to make, but some people like Ryan, Alicia and Gustavo really got into the swing of things and made more than one!

Tessellations in Year 4

In Year 4 we looked carefully at the six pattern block shapes.

Then we made tessellations (regular patterns that could carry on for ever in all directions) with some of them.

Here are the tessellations we created:

This post is also published on the Year 4 blog.

Triangle Mysteries

Here's a great pattern investigation, that got all of us in Year 5G thinking about patterns in a fresh way - fresh because we'd not come across anything quite like it before.

The activity comes from Steve Humble, and appears in the New York Times. We didn't look at the random aspect of it; we concentrated on what we could see in terms of patterns and rules.

The idea is to to start off with an empty grid like this:

You could download it yourself and have a go...

opening it in Paint. Each hexagon in the top row is filled with blue, red or yellow.

Then for the second row these are the rules:

1. If the two hexagons above are the same colour as each other, then the hexagon below is that colour. 
2. If the two hexagons above are different colours, then the hexagon below is the third colour.

Here are some of our patterns:

The patterns are great, but it was the thinking that was the most interesting part!

Here are some of our thoughts, our general statements, about the patterns. Some of them are not in fact true, some of them need investigation...

William: With some of them you turn them and you get the same pattern.

Sophia: There's often a triangle in the pattern.

Jessica: Sometimes you can guess what the colour will be at the bottom.

Chris: If you start with just red and yellow the bottom hexagon will be blue. (Is this always true??)

Christophe: The only one that doesn't have a triangle of colour in it is mine:

Florian: You never know what the colour will be at the bottom.

Jessica: You can tell if it's done correctly because usually there are downward-pointing triangles, never upward-pointing triangles.

Jessica: There is usually a pattern but not always.

Anna: The pattern still works when it is rotated.

Anna: Some of the shapes are symmetrical.

The next day, some of us had time to model a few triangle mysteries in other materials:

and in the playground -